The trip was pretty last-minute, so we didn't get tickets to any shows or anything. We had dinner in Little Italy one night, and at Bar Boulud the next (one of Daniel Boulud's restaurants) where I had a celebrity sighting that only a public radio nerd like me would be thrilled over: we saw Garrison Keillor with his family getting a table at the same restaurant!
We visited the Statue of Liberty:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/86b7d/86b7daa774e1ba6a28971d2b7e7acfc66517f8e1" alt=""
Ate chestnuts roasted on an open fire (from a street vendor):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09a1a/09a1a20c8a39f30f22d1b866f3e2d53106007959" alt=""
Looked at the beautiful Christmas decorations:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/384d2/384d28d25043b3314dd39a35c0cf0b05327e0f9e" alt=""
And went to Times Square to meet V's cousin-brother (note the Incredible India billboards you can just barely see in the background):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bb0ff/bb0ff637295638044fe1257c0dd28fe10832d864" alt=""
We also bought some Christmas gifts from interesting vendors in Chinatown; I got an expensive lipstick at Saks Fifth Avenue; braved the crowds at Tiffany's; became masters of the NYC subway system; went to the little India area in Jackson Heights for pani puri, paan, and cheap pashmina stoles; and walked around just generally enjoying the city. On Saturday night after dinner we met one of my friends at a very cool little bar near Chinatown where we drank absinthe in a cave-like room lit only by candles.
On the way home we visited V's cousin-sister and her family and had a wonderful lunch and chat with them. From their house in Jersey City, you can see the entire city of New York stretched out in front of you and the Statue of Liberty in the foreground, and as I looked at it I was kicking myself for never having been to NYC before. It was a wonderful weekend and an incredible city, and I can't wait to go back!